
This is the yearbook staff at my high school in a small town north of Seattle. I’m standing in the top row, second from left. Kristen Hannah is sitting at the far left, second from bottom with her hand on her chin.
In case you didn’t know, I participate in a weekly zoom call where we discuss politics, world events, world history and religion. All the juicy topics! A question was posed by one of the members if we’d rather have gone to college when we did and pay that tuition as opposed to today’s costs with today’s education. The second question was similar but about medical care. Would we rather pay the costs of medicine from back in the day or pay today’s prices with the advanced care?
I’ll address the university costs, but leave medical care out for now. It was interesting to hear from the four doctors in our group. They did not agree about the medical question.
Here are my thoughts on the increasing costs of college:
I went to college at the end of the ’70s and early ’80s. Very few students from my high school went to college. My graduating class of 300 students had less than 20 who pursued a college degree. Instead, many worked in their family businesses such as gas stations, shops and farms. This was in part due to living in a rural town north of Seattle. Fewer people went to college back then. Higher education was for professions such as doctors, attorneys, teachers, etc.
Fast forward to 2010 and I volunteered for a philanthropy awarding scholarships to students at Palm Springs, Cathedral City and Desert Hot Springs high schools. We read through hundreds of applications that included grades, SAT scores and personal essays.
The majority of students applying for our scholarships were of course taking out loans. They were told by their families and teachers that you had to go to college to be successful.
I discovered many had a trend of extremely low SAT scores and high grades — which is not a promising path for success in college. Almost 100 percent of the students we interviewed wanted to be doctors. If the majority of people are taking out loans, I believe that’s one reason for the increased costs.
I have heard that another reason for an increase in college tuition is the number of non-professor employees.
I asked Google AI the following question:
“How has the ratio of professors to administration at universities changed in the last 50 years?”
ANSWER:
Over the past 50 years, the ratio of professors to administrators at U.S. universities has completely inverted, shifting from campuses where faculty outnumbered administrators to a workforce dominated by non-teaching staff.
While faculty growth has roughly tracked student enrollment, administrative and professional staff numbers have expanded exponentially.
The Shift in Ratios:
- The 1970s Baseline: In 1975, America’s colleges employed significantly more professors than administrators—roughly 446,830 professors compared to 268,952 administrators and professional staff (a ratio of roughly 1.66 faculty per administrator).
- The Modern Inversion: According to analyses of Department of Education data (1976–2018) cited by Forbes, full-time faculty grew by roughly 92% (closely mirroring the 78% growth in student enrollment). Over that same span, full-time administrators grew by 164%, and “other non-faculty professionals” (such as admissions, compliance, student affairs, and IT) skyrocketed by 452%.
- Research Universities: At top public and private research universities, non-faculty staff now heavily outnumber teaching faculty. For example, a 2023 study of the top 50 U.S. universities found an average of 1 faculty member per 11 students, compared to 1 non-faculty employee per 4 students (excluding hospital staff)—meaning roughly 2.75 non-faculty staff for every 1 professor.
Do you have any thoughts on the increasing costs of higher education?
Would you rather pay the costs for medical care from when you were young or have today’s medical advances and high costs?
